Chalkbeat’s Code of Ethics
Chalkbeat is a nonprofit news organization covering educational change efforts in local communities across the country. Our mission is to provide deep, local coverage of education policy and practice to inform the decisions and actions that lead to better outcomes for children and families, especially those in low-income communities.
This mission demands that our readers and sources alike be able to have the utmost confidence in the accuracy of our journalism; the fairness of our reporting process; and the independence of our news judgments from the influence of advocates and financial supporters.
One way we protect our commitment to accuracy, integrity, and independence is by actively designing a business model that relies on diversified streams of support. Our revenue sources include major donations from foundations and individuals; contributions from readers; paid sponsorships that appear on our website and email newsletters; paid sponsorships of our live events; and a paid jobs board. We believe the more diverse our revenue sources, the more solid our independence and the stronger our prospects for long-term sustainability.
In addition to building a business model that bolsters our independence, we have also adopted a code of ethics to govern the conduct of our team members and those we work with.
The Chalkbeat code of ethics draws inspiration from those of other nonprofit news organizations, including the Marshall Project, ProPublica, Texas Tribune, and the Center for Investigative Reporting, and from those of professional organizations such as the Education Writers Association and the Society for Professional Journalists. Our code of ethics also reflects longstanding values and standards of practice of the journalism profession. Exceptional circumstances may require exceptions to this code, and we will revise it as our experiences and norms in journalism and digital media evolve.
Our stories are accurate
Journalism must be accurate, fair, and clear if readers are to trust it. To build trust, Chalkbeat journalists will:
- Check facts; correct errors transparently and swiftly; and learn from mistakes so that they aren’t repeated. If you find an error, email firstname.lastname@example.org.
- Never plagiarize and never deliberately distort facts or context, including visual information. (Plagiarism and deliberate distortion are grounds for discipline, including termination.)
- Identify the sources of their reporting, whether the information comes from people, documents, or exclusive reporting that appeared elsewhere.
- Seek independent verification from multiple sources to confirm (or contradict) claims, especially those made by public officials or anyone with an agenda beyond merely reporting the truth.
- Work to the best of their ability to assess evidence and claims without bias, always examining ways in which personal experiences and values may shape our reporting.
- Provide context that readers need to make sense of the facts.
- Acknowledge areas of uncertainty, which will always exist despite our best efforts to resolve them.
Our newsgathering is conducted comprehensively, ethically, and transparently.
Reporting about schools involves developing sources who do not interact frequently with journalists, including children and educators whose work has historically taken place outside of public view. To ensure that we minimize harm while maximizing truth, Chalkbeat journalists:
- Identify ourselves to sources openly and accurately, never misrepresenting ourselves to get a story. When we seek an interview, we identify ourselves as Chalkbeat journalists and explain how our reporting might be used.
- Avoid using unnamed sources whenever possible. When sources who are providing insights that others could also provide seek to keep their name out of our reporting, make every effort to speak to find someone else.
- Recognize that educators can be vulnerable to negative consequences of speaking to the press, and so it may be appropriate to cite unnamed educators when reporting about the effects of programs or policies on the classroom. Editors should make that call, and a story should never rely on a single unnamed educator to provide such insights.
- Show compassion for those who may be affected adversely by news coverage. Use special sensitivity when dealing with children and inexperienced sources or subjects. In the case of writing about elementary and middle school students, Chalkbeat journalists will make every effort to reach the parents, guardians, or advocates of students in three cases: when they speak to the student without an adult’s knowledge; when the student will receive prominent attention in our story; and when a student is providing information that could reflect negatively on themselves or others.
- Explain why a source is not named when using an anonymous source is unavoidable and appropriate, and negotiate with those sources to provide readers with as much information as possible about them so that readers can assess the sources’ reliability.
- Share information about sources with editors, so that editors and reporters can jointly assess whether and how to use the information they have provided. Any anonymous quotes must reflect conversation between a reporter and editor.
- Have clear conversations with sources about how to use the information they provide, especially when the sources do not have significant media experience. Clarify a source’s expectations for keeping information “off the record,” “on background,” and other statuses because those terms can mean different things to different people.
- Give people the right to respond to reporting that might portray them in a negative light, and explain to readers the efforts we went to seek a response in cases where sources do not respond.
- Actively seek sources who lack access to broad public platforms, in addition to documenting the claims of those with influence and power.
Our journalism reflects our independent conclusions.
Education debates can be highly polarized, and Chalkbeat provides balanced, unbiased, fact-based coverage aimed at informing the public conversation. To ensure that we remain independent and trustworthy, Chalkbeat team members will not:
- Seek or accept secondary employment, political involvement, and other outside activities — particularly related to education policy issues — that could compromise integrity or cause the perception of compromised integrity.
- Accept gifts, favors, fees, free travel, and special treatment from sources and potential sources. When attending events or conferences put on by sources or potential sources that offer free gift bags, reporters should decline to take any item of more than nominal value.
- Pay for access to news, either with money or other favors.
- Work on stories, projects, or initiatives in which they have a personal connection, vested interest or financial interest. This policy extends to the involvement and activities of a business partner, spouse, or domestic partner. In cases where reporters have an indirect personal connection to a story, we will always err on the side of disclosing to let readers make an independent judgment.
- Give favored treatment to sponsors and donors. Team members will resist pressure from inside or outside Chalkbeat to influence coverage because of an advocacy agenda or financial need.
- Participate in political activities such as marches and demonstrations. We will not make donations to candidates or lobbying groups.
Additionally, Chalkbeat team members will:
- Disclose the relationship whenever we produce stories that involve Chalkbeat board members or financial supporters who have given more than $1,000. When these situations arise, editors and reporters are responsible for identifying the conflict and producing a disclosure.
- Adhere to principles that protect our journalism from the influence of sponsors and donors, as outlined below.
Our donors and sponsors do not influence our reporting.
Chalkbeat is open to a wide range of financial support because we believe the more diverse our revenue sources, the more solid our independence. We have adopted a set of principles that enable us to accept this support while safeguarding our reporting from the influence of our supporters.
- Major contributions from foundations and individuals: Accepting funds from foundations and individuals is a necessity for Chalkbeat’s financial viability, but those who contribute do so knowing that our only duty is to our mission. In some cases, we accept funding to cover certain topics, if we were going to cover those topics anyway. We never accept funding for specific story ideas. Feedback from major supporters is treated like that of any entity: we listen to the feedback, but ultimately, decisions about our editorial direction are Chalkbeat’s alone. We recognize that foundations are sometimes major players in the stories we cover, and we don’t shy away from covering these stories. When we cover the work of foundations that support Chalkbeat, we disclose the relationship for the sake of full transparency.As a news organization that values transparency, Chalkbeat will always disclose the sources of gifts larger than $1,000 — both to staff and to readers.
- Website and newsletter sponsorships: Sponsors cannot influence our decisions about what to cover and how. We acknowledge sponsors on our websites and in our newsletters. We reserve the right to reject a sponsorship if we believe the content is misleading, fraudulent, or distasteful, and in no way does a sponsorship represent an endorsement from Chalkbeat. All content will be clearly labeled to be distinguishable from Chalkbeat’s editorial content.
- Events sponsorships: Event sponsors are recognized at events and in Chalkbeat’s marketing materials, but they do not co-create or influence event content. If sponsors make announcements or distribute materials at events, Chalkbeat will describe this as a paid sponsorship.
- Jobs board: Chalkbeat’s jobs board is a service to our community of readers. Job postings do not represent an endorsement from Chalkbeat of particular organizations, and the composition of postings on our jobs board does not, at any time, reflect our preferences or opinions.
- Donations from readers: Chalkbeat gladly accepts contributions from our readers. As with other donations, there is no expectation that supporting Chalkbeat will influence reporting decisions.
We acknowledge that new revenue strategies will be developed in the future that may require additional enumeration of relevant ethical policies. We assume, however, that the underlying principles will be the same, even as our strategies for serving our audience and generating revenue develop.